Why We Shouldn't Be Afraid of Church History + 3 Tools to Help Us Navigate Tough Topics
The history of The Church of Jesus Christ of
Latter-day Saints is full of beautiful moments. The First Vision, the coming
forth of the Book of Mormon, the organization of church meetings, and the
restoration of temple ordinances are all just a few examples of moments from
our history that impacted the world.
However, as with all histories, there are
moments that were not beautiful. In fact, there are moments in our history that
have caused many to doubt the truthfulness of the gospel. So do we avoid
studying Church history for fear that it will cause us to doubt as well?
Or is it that we arm ourselves with tools to help us discover
and understand our past?
"My
boss for a long time was Rick Turley, and he would always say, 'The problem is
not Church history. The problem is not reading enough Church history,'"
Latter-day Saint historian Dr. Janiece Johnson says in an LDS Living All In
podcast.
As
Latter-day Saint historians Dr. Jenny Reeder and Johnson discuss in the
podcast, history is often messy, but there are valuable lessons to be learned
from the past. To help Latter-day Saints navigate studying Church history,
Reeder and Johnson mention a few things members need to take in
consideration.
1. Understand the context.
Reeder
says often we look at Church history through a lens of presentism, meaning we
look at the past with a 21st-century point of view. Instead, we should try to
understand the context surrounding Church history events.
For example, Reeder discusses early Church
polygamy and how the women of the Church at the time had to develop their own
testimonies and witnesses of plural marriage because it was so grating to their
time and culture.
"Part of me is really grateful that I
didn't have to be there and when the clipboard was passed around in heaven, I
did not sign up for Nauvoo," Reeder says. "But part of me is
completely respectful of them and their experiences, and I believe them and I
recognize the torment they had to go through, but I also recognize the power of
personal revelation."
2. Know the source.
Reeder
says, as historians, she and Johnson are trained to be very careful when it
comes to sources. Knowing who the source is and the time period they lived in
can greatly impact the way facts are presented and the overall tone.
"There's
no such thing as an objective history," Reeder says. "It's always
subjective. You're always looking at it from a specific lens. But if you can
recognize who's talking, who's giving the sources, who's giving the facts even,
you recognize that there are some kind of biases."
In the
podcast, Reeder shares an experience where she came across some material about
Joseph Smith and plural marriage that she hadn't seen before.
"I
was sitting there and it was like my mind was being blown," Reeder says.
"I was completely disgusted. I was like, 'What is this?'"
Reeder
says when she has these moments and she prays about it and tries to use a
historian's lens, she realizes that she is looking at history with a
presentist's point of view or she looks at the source and finds they could be
someone who wrote what they did to defame the Church or its leadership.
"I
actually think the study of history has allowed me to recognize sources and to
recognize content and to recognize bias and to recognize the need for me to
find out for myself and to pray for myself," Reeder says.
Both
Reeder and Johnson suggest that if members are looking for sources about Church
history that they begin with a book like Saints and the
sources the book uses, along with the Gospel
Topics Essays.
"That
is a good jumping off place," Reeder says. "Once you understand some
of the foundation, you can dig in deeper wherever you are
interested."
3. Real life is messy.
"Real
life is messy, and understanding the past is a foreign place and it's going to
take the ability to deal with some messiness to be able to really understand
what has happened in the past," Johnson says in the podcast.
Having
worked for 10 years researching the Mountain Meadows Massacre, Johnson is no
stranger to the messy side of history.
"When
we are dealing with human beings who are limited and mortal, there is going to
be messiness," she says. "And I believe that if we approach the
messiness head on, there is strength and power in that. The gospel will still
be true. . . . As I am methodical, as I lay things out, as I try to understand
and I always use the Spirit as a guide, I'm going to be okay."
Reeder
also says that seeing the messiness in Church history has helped her in her
personal life.
"Seeing this messiness in these people's
lives from our past helps me realize that my messiness in my life is
okay," she says. "I read these women's stories to know that I am not
alone."
